“I pay myself $100,000 per year, plus all the cash I can take!”
That was the response I got when, as a young shop owner, I asked an older, established owner how much he paid himself. I was curious about how much I should make and how I should pay myself. His answer didn’t help me.
Compensation for employees is usually pretty simple. We know how to pay technicians and other employees. Flat rate within a market is pretty standard. Hourly rates are also market-driven based on job and required skill level.
But what about the owner’s paycheck? It may seem that the owner has the best job. But few understand the hours the owner puts into the business and the risk the owner has taken.
There’s a large part of ownership that no one sees. Owners sacrifice. In a very young business, they sacrifice a lot! The owner works the longest hours, sometimes with no compensation so that payroll or other expenses can be met. The owner takes out and personally guarantees business loans. The owner is also on the hook for employee mistakes and can be sued for just about anything at any time.
Owners earn compensation in two ways. First, the owner should earn a paycheck just like any other business employee for working in the business. Second, the owner should earn a return on their investment in the business.
The decision on how much an owner should or could make is best made with the advice of a good, business-focused CPA. Owners should have a complete understanding of the company profit and loss statement. Remember: If the company isn’t profitable, the owner makes no money!
As noted above, if the owner is functioning as a manager or technician (or both), the owner should draw a paycheck just like all of the other employees.
Some owners of new or smaller business may simply “draw against the net,” writing a check to themselves and posting the money as an owner’s draw against profits. Obviously, if there is no profit, the draw is taken against the owner’s equity. But there are several problems with this method of compensation. Taxes are not taken into account, and benefits aren’t included. Thus, there is a significant risk of “overdrawing” and running out of money before monthly bills are paid.
Additionally, the P&L does not reflect a true picture of the business. Since the owner’s pay comes from net profit, overhead is not accurately presented and the net profit is overstated.
It’s far better to make the owner an employee of the company so that owner compensation is shown on the P&L as an overhead expense. Taxes and benefits are deducted and paid just as with any employee, and the owner still has the option to draw additional funds from profits if warranted.
How much should you pay yourself? If the business is in its infancy, probably nothing. Remember, the company has to make a profit before anyone can be paid. Most business consultants suggest that new owners make sure they have sufficient cash on hand to go six months to one year with no income from the business. The first year is tough!
In a perfect world, the owner creates a solid business plan prior to opening the doors. That business plan may show the owner working for no compensation for the first six to 12 months, but after that initial period, the owner may plan for a minimal paycheck for the next six to 12 months, then increase owner’s compensation as the business builds.
But the world is not perfect, and most new business owners don’t plan for living on no pay for six to 12 months. The new owner may be working for nothing, but other employees are getting paid. Resentment builds, the new owner decides to pay himself too soon and cash flow issues result. Cash flow difficulty is the No. 1 cause of new business failure. As a business matures, the owner can finally receive a paycheck. That’s a good thing!
Owner pay comes in many forms. Obviously, there is the paycheck. As noted before, the owner should be paid just like any employee if the owner works in the business on a day-to-day basis. But there are other ways that the owner receives compensation, such as a company car, contribution to retirement plans, flexible hours, expense accounts, insurance benefits, etc. Work with your accountant and tax advisor to make sure those additional benefits are appropriate. It’s really hard to justify a boat, plane or RV as a reasonable business expense for a three-year-old collision center selling $80,000 per month.
One rule of thumb: if the owner manages the business day to day, the owner’s base pay should be equivalent to the amount the business would have to pay for a general manager. If a mid-sized shop in a market can attract a good manager for $75,000 per year, then $75,000 plus appropriate benefits would be a good base annual compensation for the owner.
Be careful when adding those extra benefits! The business needs to make money. Most use a minimum 10 percent of gross sales as a goal for net profit before taxes. That 10 percent net profit allows money to be reinvested in the business, loans to be paid and money to be paid to ownership as dividends if the company is a corporation. But if the total of owner’s compensation plus owner’s benefits such as the car, expenses, bonus, plane, boat and RV drive the net profit below 10 percent, the owner is being overcompensated and the business is being hurt.
What if the owner is doing work in-shop? Maybe the owner works on customer’s cars doing some body or paint work. If so, the owner should pay themselves an hourly rate or flat rate, just as the other productive employees are paid. But make sure that the total owner’s compensation does not drive that net below 10 percent of gross sales.
As the business evolves, many owners hire managers to run the company. As the owner’s active role in the business is reduced, the owner’s pay should shift from being an employee of the company to that of being a stockholder. The manager’s wages should be shown as overhead, and the owner’s pay will come as a dividend payment.
Some may wish to remain on the payroll in some capacity in order to stay on the health plan, continue to drive the company car and pay into Social Security and other taxes. That’s fine! But make sure that the owner’s compensation is not driving the net profit below that 10 percent figure.
As a business grows, its value grows as well. We all understand how a home increases in value over time, and the payoff is reduced over time by making monthly payments. The difference between the fair market value of the home and the loan payoff is the owner’s equity in the home.
Building a business is the same thing. Over time, the value of the business grows and the money owed against the business is reduced by making lease and loan payments.
While business valuation is a complex issue, there are two basic methods of determining the value of any business: cash flow or net asset value.
Net asset value is usually used to value a poorly performing business or one that’s very heavily invested in inventory. The business is worth its “net assets,” usually as shown on the balance sheet.
Owner Pay Do’s and Don’ts
Pay yourself a salary within the first six months to a year of owning the business
Allow your compensation to drive net sales below 10 percent
Take cash from your business
Pay yourself via a paycheck like a regular employee
Pay yourself a minimal paycheck after the first six months to a year
Increase your compensation as your business builds
Pay yourself (if you manage the business) the amount the business would have to pay for a general manager
Cash flow valuation uses the net positive cashflow to determine the value. In this method, the net positive cash flow (usually EBIDTA or Earnings Before Interest, Depreciation, Taxes and Amortization) is multiplied by a number to arrive at the business value. The number, or multiplier, is a negotiated number representing the number of years the buyer is allowing the net positive cashflow to repay the investment made in buying the business.
Example: A collision center has a net positive cash flow of $150,000 per year. It has a strong business, is well managed without the owner’s full-time involvement, has a solid crew and has shown several years of positive sales growth. Using that information, the owner negotiates a multiplier of 3.5. The business has a value of $525,000 ($150,000 x 3.5). Remember, that does not include the real estate! In selling the business, the owner should negotiate a fair market rent for the property.
Rental income is an area frequently overlooked as owner compensation. Often, the business owns the real estate housing the company. As time passes, the loan balance diminishes while the fair market lease rate increases. The building and business should be separate entities, with the business paying a fair market rent to the owner of the real estate, usually the owner of the business. The difference between the fair market rent and the payment can be income to the owner. In our example, the owner will receive $525,000 for the business plus rental income from the property.
Rental income provides a terrific tool for allowing continuing income to a parent who’s leaving the business to their children or selling the business to an outside entity or MSO.
Business owners should keep an eye on equity as they build their business. To maximize equity, the business must be profitable, should show steady sales growth and be systems driven so that the company is not dependent on the owner for daily operations.
To illustrate the point, let’s remember the line given by the veteran shop owner at the introduction of this article: “I pay myself $100,000 per year, plus all the cash I can take!” Taking cash from the business may seem like a good thing on the surface. Naturally, taking cash avoids paying income tax and other taxes on the revenue. That’s why it’s illegal. But taking cash also causes a significant negative impact to the owner’s equity in the business. Let’s say the owner “pocketed” the customer’s $250 deductible, which was paid in cash. Being a smart owner, he backed the $250 out of the RO so that the sales and deposits matched, thinking no one would catch him. (Hint: The IRS can, and they do catch that!)
The owner has money in his wallet, but that money did not go through the business and did not show up in sales. In fact, that $250 came right out of net profit! Since the business value is based on steady sales volume and profitability, taking that $250 reduces the net positive cashflow and the multiplier. If we use a multiplier of three, that $250 cost the owner $750 in business equity! Plus, the owner now has to wonder if “they” will catch up to him. All that to save $50 in taxes?
There is no simple answer to the question, “How much should I make as the owner of a collision center?” But we can illustrate a solid owner’s compensation plan.
Let’s assume that the owner also manages a collision center. The shop is doing $2 million per year in annual sales and has a net profit margin of 10 percent, or $200,000. The owner is being paid a monthly salary plus benefits, with a company car and expense account. The owner also owns the property, which has a fair market rent value of $10,000 per month. Loan payments plus maintenance expenses, insurance and reserves total $8,000 per month. A good general manager would cost $80,000 per year.
A fair owner’s compensation would be a base pay of $80,000 per year plus the current benefits. Additionally, since the business is profitable, the owner may reasonably take a quarterly dividend of 30 percent ($60,000) of the net profit. That would probably be paid on a quarterly basis, leaving 70 percent of the net to be reinvested in the business. The owner is also making $2,000 per month as rent.
Let’s add it up: Base pay of $80,000 plus benefits, $60,000 in dividend income, $24,000 in rental income = $164,000 in annual income. Plus, as time passes, the owner is earning increased equity in both the real estate and the business.
Yes, that’s a simplistic illustration. The numbers and percentages used are for illustration only. In the real world, owners should work with their accountants to decide just how much the business can afford to pay the owner and how to structure that compensation in such a way that tax impacts are minimized. In our example, maybe that dividend being taken should be made as a 401K contribution?
By truly understanding the financial structure of a business, and working with a business-focused CPA or accountant, a good compensation structure can be created for the owner.
When vandals dent a vehicle or a collision crumples the body of a car, auto body repair technicians -- often just called auto body repairers -- can repair the damage. They work indoors in repair shops that are noisy but well-ventilated to whisk away dust and fumes. Workers use protective clothing and safety procedures to avoid cuts, burns and bruises.
Auto body repair technicians received a mean $21.94 per hour or $45,630 per year as of May 2017, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The top 10% of auto body repair techs earn more than $33.98 per hour or $70,670 per year, while the worst-paid 10% make just $12.24 per hour or $25,470 per year. To make this money, technicians examine damage, prepare cost estimates and plan the work. They remove defective parts, hammer out or patch dents and other minor body damage, weld or attach replacement parts, sand and buff surfaces, and apply new paint and other coatings to restored areas.
Auto body repairers can learn their trade in two ways. The first is without any formal education under the guidance of a more experienced worker or the shop supervisor. The second is through a formal postsecondary training program that can last from six months to two years. Although it usually takes only a year to learn the basics, workers typically need three or four years of practical experience to become fully qualified. Continuing education is a must to keep up with fast-changing automobile technology. Certification is not required but is available from national organizations, and can make jobs easier to find.
Pay by Industry
Of the 144,320 auto body repair techs that worked in the country in 2017, around 70 percent were employed by automotive repair and maintenance shops. Pay here ran a mean of $21.84 per hour or $45,420 per year. Car dealers provided almost 20 percent of the jobs with mean salaries of $21.97 per hour or $45,690 per year. Wholesalers of motor vehicles and their parts rounded out the top three, averaging $20.80 per hour or $43,260 per year. The industry with the highest salary was the U.S. Postal Service, which employed 190 techs and paid a mean $29.81 per hour or $62,000 per year.
Pay by Location
The state with the most employment for the profession was California, the most populous state in the United States. It contained 14,040 of the jobs at mean wages of $23.66 per hour or $49,210. With 11,350 workers, Texas, the second-most populous state, ranked second for opportunities and had mean salaries at $20.59 per hour or $42,820 per year. Florida, Illinois and New York rounded out the top five. Some states with the least employment for auto repair techs included Wyoming, Montana, Vermont and Delaware. In metropolitan areas, Chicago topped the list for jobs with 4,660 of the positions at a mean pay of $24.08 per hour or $50,090 per year.